Collectors Club
Grading Census

AGS Population Report

Every card AGS has ever graded, counted by grade. Drill from category to set to a single card to see exactly how rare each grade really is.

Pin Club x Nightfall Mystery Collection — grade distribution

47

Total graded

19%

Gem-MT 10 rate

19%

Gem + Legendary

98%

Mint 9 or better

Gem 10 / LegendaryMint 9–9.5 / NM-MT 8EX–NM (5–7.5)VG 3 & below
CardLegendGem 109.598Gem rateTotal
Mothman

Mothman

1st Edition - Holo

05111029%17
Wendigo

Wendigo

1st Edition - Holo

005100.0%7
Headless Horseman

Headless Horseman

1st Edition - Holo

0250029%7
Mothman

Mothman

1st Edition - Holo

0130025%4
Wendigo

Wendigo

1st Edition - Holo

003100.0%4
Teakettler

Teakettler

1st Edition

0130025%4
Headless Horseman

Headless Horseman

1st Edition - Holo

002100.0%3
Teakettler

Teakettler

1st Edition - Holo

001000.0%1
Feu Follet

Feu Follet

1st Edition

00000—0
A-Mi-Kuk

A-Mi-Kuk

1st Edition

00000—0
Poltergeist

Poltergeist

1st Edition

00000—0
Flying Manta Ray

Flying Manta Ray

1st Edition

00000—0
Wood Devil Of Coos County

Wood Devil Of Coos County

1st Edition

00000—0
Crazy Critter Of Bald Mountain

Crazy Critter Of Bald Mountain

1st Edition

00000—0
Ingrid Cold

Ingrid Cold

1st Edition

00000—0
Momo

Momo

1st Edition

00000—0
The Red Ghost

The Red Ghost

1st Edition

00000—0
Adam Ackler

Adam Ackler

1st Edition

00000—0
Kinderhook Blob

Kinderhook Blob

1st Edition

00000—0

19 entries

Population data courtesy of AGS (agscard.com). Figures update as new grades are recorded.